Fed Policy Rules vs. Discretion: A Rule for the Money Supply
Published · Updated
Inflation is a monetary phenomenon, and a precommitted rule beats meeting-by-meeting discretion. The figures are the feeds. The preference is this paper’s.
A rule would have told a reader, before a meeting, how the bounds on the cost of money would move if the price level did a named thing. A discretionary committee does not owe that sentence. The tradeoff is real. A rule can miss a shock it did not name, and then it binds. Discretion can answer the shock, and then nobody outside the room knew the answer in advance. This paper takes the rule.
The preference is not a Federal Reserve finding. It does not depend on which party holds the presidency or the chair. The figures are the target bounds, the price index as an index, the balance-sheet total in the unit the feed named, and bank credit in the unit the feed named. None of those prints is turned into a rate of change here.
FRED prints a federal-funds target upper limit of 4.00% and a lower limit of 3.75%, as of Nov 19, 2026.
The consumer price index is 337.476 as of October 2026. The feed names the unit Index 1982-1984=100. That figure is the index. This paper does not turn it into an inflation rate. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (Consumer Price Index), via GOVSPENDING.ORG.
Total assets on the weekly statement are 6,758,867 as of Nov 11, 2026. The feed’s unit is Millions of U.S. Dollars. The number is not rescaled. Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (H.4.1 Factors Affecting Reserve Balances), via GOVSPENDING.ORG.
Bank credit at commercial banks is 20,083.1228 as of Nov 4, 2026. The feed’s unit is Billions of U.S. Dollars. The number is not rescaled. Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (H.8 Assets and Liabilities of Commercial Banks), via GOVSPENDING.ORG.
A rule would have named, in advance, how those bounds move. A meeting can answer a shock the rule did not name, and then the public learns the answer afterward. This paper takes the rule. It does not pretend the Federal Reserve has adopted that preference.